« Sydney & Auckland Programmes: July 2008 | Main | Situated cognition »

Not everyone has to do the same thing

Controversy on the BBC breakfast news this morning about drop out rates from Universities.  Looks like its about 14% entrants leave early.  The official spokesperson came up with the classic phrase used by government officials in trouble: We've got to redefine what success and failure is.  She also provided a terribly patronising series of comments mostly in the form of platitudes.  In the past many people from working class backgrounds made it into University through scholarships and then, in the sixties and seventies where education was fully funded if you were academic enough to make it we got massive social mobility. 

About 5% of the population went to University in those days and you were not considered a failure of you did not go.  It was a recognition of the need for investment in research and intellectual development that a civilised society should provide, and a recognition that such investment is necessarily limited.  We also had vocational courses and polytechnics which added huge value to a diverse system.  All the Polytechnics are now rebranded as Universities and  everyone is meant to go to university (measuring success by numbers not quality).  We have created the conditions for failure.  Also we can't afford to fund it properly so student loans are the solution which of course rewards the Middle Class.

Comments (2)

Charles Lam [TypeKey Profile Page]:

Some comments from HK:

My dad always told me how hard it was to get a bachelor degree back then and it was seen as a major achievement. Now U-grads are everywhere... that's not the point though... I have a few uncles who did not have the luxury to get a degree (could not afford it)... the amazing thing is how they speak (and write) way better English than the "U-grads" nowadays... that's a foreign language to us... hm... but the "uncles" are also way better in Cantonese (Chinese).

Is it the quality of the education system or are we ("U-grads") just a bunch of spoiled kids who take things (incl. opportunities) for granted?

Btw, I am a subscriber of your blog :) Love your ideas!!!

Charles.

There are several issues and debates that could arise out of this, but the one I'd like to pick up on is: why is a 14% drop-out rate poor?

It is simply impossible that 100% of the entrants to a programme of study have made the right choice. Good grief! How many 18 year olds really know what they want to when they "grow up"? There are so many options and paths available, I can't believe that only 1 in 7 realises they've got it wrong during the course of their 3 years.

Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)