« British Airways | Main | Well said .. »

KM Brazil

It has been a busy year for KM conference keynotes. KM Australia, was followed up by KM Asia, KM World in the US, KM India (by phone) a few in the UK and now KM Brazil. I was given two hours today so could cover a lot of material, although I was tired at the end (keeping the right speed for translators) and the audience were in part exhausted. The slides are available here and while it was not podcast, some of the material was covered in KM World and in my podcast with Jon.

Several good conversations before and afterwards. One of the more distressing things however (and I have said this around the world) is the tendency to take on board US approaches more or less as they are described by the consultants who sell them. We have BPR and SAP implementations out here with knowledge management in its early days. I sometimes think that consultants and software companies start off in their own country, exhaust that market (and the patience of executives for yet another initiative) and then move on overseas, or into Government (the industrial best practice con trick).

You cannot take a method and approach developed in one context, and then apply it wholesale to a different one. I argued strongly that we need countries like Brazil (and Singapore, and South Africa and, and, and...) to learn from but not imitate the reported best practice of US companies. I say reported deliberately as I am dubious as to the reality of case studies used. Those countries have unique advantages, they can create new and culturally relevant ways of sharing and creating knowledge. The US is a unique culture that has driven much, for good an ill. However it is not anti-american to say that it would be a very bad thing if it became the template that the world attempted to follow.

Comments (1)

stuart:

Hi Dave

The problem you describe has always intrigued me.

Thinking about the giant ERP implementations that I was involved with in the late 1990's in the private sector and all the things we learnt about how not to do it.

I found the same mistakes, the same consultants and the same software being peddled a few years later in the public sector under the e-government banner.

I advised a number of clients not to follow certain paths, passing on the benefit of all my hard found wisdom, but they ploughed on regardless.

It was if, like teenagers, they had to learn for themselves rather than take my advice. Pity they were using our tax pounds to fund the experiment.!

This is the idea of 'learning by doing' on a macro scale. Just returned from India and similar is happening there.

Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)